Critical Assessment of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act
The Dodd-Frank Reform Bill is regarded as one of the largest financial reform bill in the past 70+ years that addresses the systemic risks and stability problems associated with the banking and finance industry. It addresses “too big to fail”, regulatory issues, expanding the responsibility of the Federal Reserve, implementing a variant of the Glass-Steagall (Volcker Rule), and increased transparency across the industry. Although this bill is intended to do some good, it has some shortcomings…
Below is an excerpt from “A Critical Assessment of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act” on http://www.nakedcapitalism.com:
That said, from the standpoint of providing a sound and robust regulatory structure, the Act falls flat on at least four important counts:
- The Act does not deal with the mispricing of pervasive government guarantees throughout the financial sector.
This will allow many financial firms to finance their activities at below-market rates and take on excessive risk.
- Systemically important firms will be made to bear their own losses but not the costs they impose on others in the system.
To this extent, the Act falters in addressing directly the primary source of market failure in the financial sector, which is systemic risk.
- In several parts, the Act regulates a financial firm by its form (bank) rather than function (banking).
This feature will prevent the Act from dealing well with the new organisational forms likely to emerge in the financial sector – to meet the changing needs of global capital markets, as well as to respond to the Act’s provisions.
- The Act makes important omissions in reforming and regulating parts of the shadow banking system that are systemically important.
It also fails to recognise that there are systemically important markets – collections of individual contracts and institutions – that also need orderly resolution when they experience freezes.”
(excerpt written by: Viral Acharya, Professor of Finance, Stern School of Business, New York University, Thomas F. Cooley Professor of Economics, Stern School of Business and Faculty of Arts and Science, New York University, Matthew Richardson, Professor of Applied Economics, Stern School of Business, New York University, Richard Sylla, Professor of Economics, Stern School of Business, New York University and Ingo Walter, Seymour Milstein Professor of Finance, Corporate Governance and Ethics at the Stern School of Business, New York University. Cross-posted from VoxEU)
Thus, even with the passing of this new reform act and all its good intentions, there probably won’t be a huge, sweeping paradigm shift in the way that banking and business will be done in this country. Instead, it will just impede some parts of banking business in Wall Street, but ultimately allow for new ways for banks to make sure they can continue to make their exorbitant profits in high risk environments with lack of regard for the rest of the consumer base.
Read the rest of the article here…